Range Widely
Subscribe
Cover photo

"War and Peace" and Ukraine

Tolstoy's argument against the "Great Man Theory" of heroism

David Epstein

Feb 28
12

I wasn’t planning to write about Ukraine this week. If you’re looking for a newsletter with expert commentary about Ukraine, I recommend Ian Bremmer’s GZERO World.

That said, images from the last week of individual defiance are seared into my brain:

-The Ukrainian woman who insisted that Russian soldiers take her sunflower seeds and put them in their pockets, so at least sunflowers will grow from the ground on which they die.

-Videos of unarmed Ukrainians trying to block tanks or other vehicles, in groups, or alone.

-The so-called “Battle of Snake Island,” in which a Russian Navy ship ordered the border guards on a tiny island to surrender, and one of the guards replied: “Russian warship, go fuck yourself.” Audio of the encounter was posted online, and went viral. (The border guards were initially reported dead, but subsequent reports suggest that they were taken as prisoners.)

-The Ukrainian president — a comedian and actor until a few years ago — posting videos to say “I am still here,” and responding to the U.S. offer of evacuation with: “I need ammunition, not a ride.”

-Russians in Moscow, who knew the consequences, arrested on their way to demonstrate.

WHAT WOULD TOLSTOY SAY?

With each image like that, my mind returns to Leo Tolstoy’s epic novel War and Peace. Given that it’s more than 150 years old, I think it’s fair to share spoilers.

As Henry James said, the book contains “all of life.” And yet, as it goes on, a specific agenda emerges: War and Peace is an argument against the so-called “Great Man Theory” of history. That is, the idea that most people have no effect on the world, and it’s really a tiny number of geniuses or heroic leaders who turn the gears of history.

Tolstoy, who in the 1850s served in the Crimean War, went to great lengths to argue the opposite — that history should be studied not as a series of brilliant decisions by a small number of geniuses, but more like calculus: the summation of an infinite number of small actions that together produce change. He used historical documents and battleground visits to show that, throughout the Napoleonic wars, a top commander’s strategy was rarely carried out faithfully by actors on the ground, who had to improvise repeatedly. In many cases, commanders issued orders that were simply impossible to follow.

In this light, insisting that history is being written only via the decisions of those few military geniuses makes no sense. Tolstoy argued that historians believed the "Great Man Theory" only because they focused on the plans and letters that generals (particularly their own country’s generals) left behind.

In War and Peace, Napoleon is the embodiment of this phenomenon. By the time reports of battlefield events went up the chain of command and reached him, they were already old; he would then issue new orders based on that old information; by the time the new orders got back to the battlefield, they were completely irrelevant; new reports were then sent back to Napoleon, and the cycle of irrelevant commands and useless reports would repeat.

One of the unusual heroes in the book is a Russian general who — realizing the futility of trying to choreograph action that is the accumulation of many rapid individual decisions — decided to just say that things are going according to plan, and prioritized troop morale and a good night’s sleep for his soldiers.

Tolstoy unrelentingly points out how the actions of supposedly singular geniuses like Napoleon are less significant than they believe; he emphasizes the impact that individuals on the ground can sometimes have in war, especially when they react quickly — almost unthinkingly. Those individuals don’t have a grand strategy, but happen to respond in a moment when their action can galvanize the spirit of a much larger group. It isn’t even what the individual intends, but by chance, their spirit spreads like a contagion.

In one battle in War and Peace, Russian soldiers are beginning to panic and fall into disarray, when a single man charges out of the forest at the advancing French with “wild and drunken zeal,” armed with nothing but a sword. The French are stunned by the reckless act, and the moment of pause halts the snowballing Russian panic.

THE IMAGES FROM UKRAINE

I wonder how each of the heroic images coming from Ukraine will impact the spirit of people across the country, and in neighboring countries, and around the world. Perhaps they will just be viral pictures and videos, and that will be it. Or perhaps they will (or already did) engender the larger, ineffable collective spirit that Tolstoy described.

As Russian-born American journalist Julia Ioffe explained to Stephen Colbert: Ukrainians have only had experience with democracy “for a couple decades, and look how hard they’re fighting for it.”

OTHER RESOURCES (AND THINK BEFORE YOU SHARE PICS)

A lot of images and videos purportedly from the current fighting in Ukraine are burning around social media, and a lot of them are actually older, or from other places. So be careful what you share. It's hard to be perfect, but it's easy to do a little quick checking and lower your error rate. On that point, and in general, here are a few resources I’ve found interesting or useful:

-If you aren’t familiar with it, this is a great time to learn how to reverse image search before you share a picture. Here’s a very simple explainer.

-The incredible open-source investigative team at Bellingcat is tracking disinformation.

-Again, Ian Bremmer’s GZERO World is an informative newsletter. I started reading GZERO World before this week, but didn’t realize how long Ian has been covering pertinent issues. Over the weekend, I came upon his 1994 journal article: “The Politics of Ethnicity: Russians in the New Ukraine.” Ian seems highly attuned to complexity. I appreciated this line toward the end of the paper: “Piecing together a Ukrainian interethnic picture on the result of one set of all-Ukraine data is somewhat like taking an average temperature reading in a hospital, where the mean hides the extremes.”

-A few years ago, I read Garry Kasparov’s 2015 book on Putin, Winter Is Coming. It feels very prescient right now, and the ebook is on sale for $2.99.

-Fiona Hill and Clifford Gaddy’s Mr. Putin: Operative in the Kremlin, is an extraordinary deep dive into Putin’s life and motivations. It’s also an interesting warning regarding interpreting stories about Putin, since so many of them were seeded or altered by him. (Every interview with Fiona Hill is its own little history lesson. Here's a fascinating — and harrowing — interview that published yesterday.)

-Novaya Gazeta is reportedly one of Russia’s few remaining independent news sources. Last year, the head editor won a Nobel Peace Prize. You can hit the translate button and read it here. If you saw the viral footage of a captured Russian officer, you can read Novaya Gazeta’s interview with that officer’s sister.

Thank you for reading. If you'd like to share this post, here's a link. As always, you can subscribe here. Until next week...

David

Subscribe for free to Range Widely
By subscribing, you agree to share your email address with David Epstein to receive their original content, including promotions. Unsubscribe at any time. Meta will also use your information subject to the Bulletin Terms and Policies
12

More from Range Widely
See all

How Film Editing Made Me a Better Writer

A simple mental model got thoughts out of my head and onto the page
Jan 11
45

If Humans Came From Apes, Why Are There Still Cats and Bananas?

What a Senate Candidate Doesn’t Get About Evolution
Mar 21
44

The Best Opening Lines Of 2021

From 7 words to 172 words, these were the best opening lines I read this year
Dec 28, 2021
33
Comments
Log in with Facebook to comment

12 Comments

  • Ian Bremmer
    Writes GZERO World with Ian Bremmer
    solid piece, man. and thanks for the shoutout. you must be the third or fourth person to read my dissertation...
    • 9w
  • Matthew Valkovic
    Thanks David. Always enjoy your newsletters and recommend "Range" whenever I can.
    Your discussion of Tolstoy reminded me of a concept I learned about when I was in the Army trying to understand counterinsurgency. It's called the "strategic corporal" a…
    See more
    Krulak Revisited: The Three-Block War, Strategic Corporals, and the Future Battlefield - Modern War Institute
    MWI.USMA.EDU
    Krulak Revisited: The Three-Block War, Strategic Corporals, and the Future Battlefield - Modern War Institute
    Krulak Revisited: The Three-Block War, Strategic Corporals, and the Future Battlefield - Modern War Institute
    2
    • 11w
    • Edited
    • Author
      David Epstein
      Well, Matthew, it's happened a few times since I started this newsletter that someone leaves a comment that's more interesting to me than my own post. This is definitely one of those times. You've also added to my reading list here. I really appreciate…
      See more
      • 11w
    View 1 more reply
  • Matt Thomas
    Thanks for this one, David! I haven't read War and Peace yet, but when you mentioned it in a previous newsletter and comment, I bought my own used copy online in the translation you recommended. So I tried to parse through the newsletter without readin…
    See more
    • 11w
    • Author
      David Epstein
      Hahaha...Matt, you're a gentleman and a scholar;) I want to give you a few quick W&P tips that aren't spoilers: the maps in the back help when you get to battles, just to understand what's going on; notes in the back are sometimes very neat, like those…
      See more
      • 10w
      • Edited
  • William Murphy
    Thanks for this David, it's nice to hear some of your take on the topic that has dominated world news for the past week and a bit, just when we seemed to have reached a watershed with the pandemic.... this "Great Man Theory" is fascinating, it's a bit …
    See more
    • 11w
    • Author
      David Epstein
      William, I never don't enjoy your comments. I don't think that's really off topic at all. The character in W&P who realizes he should focus on soldier sleep is a general named Kutuzov, who is alternately a goat and a hero, both for things not really in…
      See more
      Coach K: I learned to 'ignore' from Chuck Daly - ESPN Video
      ESPN.COM
      Coach K: I learned to 'ignore' from Chuck Daly - ESPN Video
      Coach K: I learned to 'ignore' from Chuck Daly - ESPN Video
      2
      • 11w
    View 1 more reply
  • Ziwei Zhang
    Hi David, thank you for your unique insight! I found Tolstoy's take on the "Great Man Theory" is very interesting, and his argument is not only relevant to the history of war but also to the dynamics of different social groups. It also applies to scien…
    See more
    • 11w
    • Author
      David Epstein
      Ziwei, thanks so much for this comment! That's a great point about science. I was actually just reading some sociology of science, particularly about "multiple discovery," the phenomenon of different people or groups coming up with the same breakthroug…
      See more
      • 10w
  • William Keller
    A friend of mine indicated that the "Go fuck yourself" comment was a bit of a poor translation, and colloquially should be better translated as "Go jump on a dick"
    • 9w
Share quoteSelect how you’d like to share below
Share on Facebook
Share to Twitter
Send in Whatsapp
Share on Linkedin
Privacy  ·  Terms  ·  Cookies  ·  © Meta 2022
Discover fresh voices. Tune into new conversations. Browse all publications